Skip to main content

Table 2 Client-specific outcome measures (CSOM)

From: Clinical validity of outcome pain measures in naturally occurring canine osteoarthritis

 

Time

Median (range)

Statistical comparison

OR (95% LCL – UCL)

Chi square

P

Act(1)

D0

2 (0 – 4)

D0 vs. D30

2.6(1.0 – 6.9)

4.9

0.04

D30

1 (1 – 3)

D0 vs. D90

5.3(1.3 – 21.3)

5.5

0.019

D90

1 (0 – 3)

D30 vs. D90

1.9(0.5 – 7.1)

1.1

0.29

Act(2)

D0

2 (1 – 4)

D0 vs. D30

3.5*(1.3 – 9.2)

6.4

0.011

D30

2 (0 – 4)

D0 vs. D90

8.7*(2.2 – 34.1)

9.7

0.0018

D90

1 (0 – 2)

D30 vs. D90

2.5(0.8 – 6.9)

3

0.08

Act(3)

D0

2 (1 – 3)

D0 vs. D30

1.8(0.8 – 4.2)

2.0

0.15

D30

2 (0 – 3)

D0 vs. D90

2.8(0.9 – 8.4)

3.3

0.06

D90

1 (0 – 4)

D30 vs. D90

1.5(0.4 – 5.0)

0.5

0.47

Act(4)

D0

2 (1 – 4)

D0 vs. D30

2.0(0.8 – 4.7)

2.5

0.10

D30

2 (0 – 4)

D0 vs. D90

4.2(1.1 – 16.2)

4.4

0.03

D90

2 (0 – 4)

D30 vs. D90

2.1(0.7 – 5.9)

2.0

0.15

Act(5)

D0

2 (1 – 3)

D0 vs. D30

_

9.1

0.02

CMH

D30

2 (0 – 3)

D0 vs. D90

_

7.5

0.05

 

D90

1 (0 – 3)

D30 vs. D90

_

3.5

0.17

Ctg(1)

D0

2 (1 – 4)

D0 vs. D30

2.7*(1.4 – 5.3)

8.3

0.004

D30

2 (0 – 2)

D0 vs. D90

2.6(1.7 – 6.6)

4.6

0.03

D90

1 (0 – 3)

D30 vs. D90

0.9(0.4 – 2.1)

0.4

0.97

Ctg(2)

D0

2.5 (0 – 3)

D0 vs. D30

10.5*(1.5 – 72.0)

5.7

0.016

D30

2 (0 – 2)

D0 vs. D90

32.7*(2.3 – 457.0)

6.7

0.009

D90

1 (0 – 2)

D30 vs. D90

3.1(0.7 – 13.3)

2.3

0.12

Ctg(3)

D0

2 (1 – 4)

D0 vs. D30

0.8(0.3 – 2.3)

0.1

0.73

D30

2 (1 – 4)

D0 vs. D90

0.6(0.2 – 1.6)

0.8

0.35

D90

2 (0 – 3)

D30 vs. D90

0.2(0.2 – 4.7)

0.09

0.76

Ctg(4)

D0

2 (2 – 2)

D0 vs. D30

_

4.1

0.25

CMH

D30

2 (1 – 2)

D0 vs. D90

_

13.0♦

0.011

 

D90

1 (0 – 2)

D30 vs. D90

_

6.6

0.08

Ctg(5)

D0

2 (2 – 3)

D0 vs. D30

_

0.11

0.73

CMH

D30

1.5 (1 – 2)

D0 vs. D90

_

0.55

0.45

 

D90

1 (1 – 2)

D30 vs. D90

_

0.11

0.73

  1. Selected activities, Act(1) to Act(5) ranked by decrescendo order of importance by owner. Selected behavioural categories, Ctg (1) : Reduced mobility; Ctg (2) : Reduced mobility after exercise; Ctg (3) : Reduced ability to change posture; Ctg (4) : Reduced ability to change posture after rest or in the morning; Ctg (5) : Resistance to manipulations. LCL: lower control limit; UCL: upper control limit.
  2. Multinomial logistic regression for repeated measures: *significant odds ratio (OR). Cochran-Mantel-Haenszel (CMH) test: ♦significant row mean scores difference (RMSD). Estimates were significant P-value (P) lower than 0.017 with Bonferroni’s adjustment.